Category: Trade Shows

CES 2013: From Hype to Ho-Hum in Minutes

Here we go again ! (Sigh…)

Here we go again ! (Sigh…)

Things are booming in the world of consumer electronics, regardless of the state of the world’s economy. You needed no additional proof beyond the enormous turnout at last week’s International CES, which was in excess of 150,000, according to official press releases. Even if you apply the Kell factor, that’s still a huge turnout – at least 120,000.

I’ve used an easy rule to determine attendance: How long it takes to catch a cab at the end of the first two days of the show. 10 minutes? Light turnout. 20 minutes? Respectable turnout. 40 minutes or more? Now, that’s a crowd!

I spent the equivalent of three full days at the show, scrambling back and forth between strip hotels and the convention center, capturing over 1200 videos and photos along the way. After a while, it all started to blur together. I mean; how many 110-inch TVs do you have to see before the “awe” wears off? How many tablets will you run across before you swear never to touch another one?

This year’s edition of show was characterized by a level playing field across many technologies. No longer do the Japanese and Koreans have an exclusive right to “first to market.” Their neighbors across the sea are now just as technically competent, if not more so.


Hisense’s “Big Bertha” uses the same glass as TVs shown by TCL, Samsung, and Westinghouse Digital.


Everybody (and their brother) had an 84-inch 4K TV at the show. (Yawn…)

Case in point: The 110-inch 4K LCD TVs shown at CES (I counted four of them, including one in the Samsung booth) all use glass from a Chinese LCD fab known as China Star Optoelectronics Technology, which is a three-year old joint venture between TCL, Samsung, and the local government of Shenzen.

Never heard of them? You will. What’s even more amazing is that their Gen 8.5 LCD fab is (according to an industry insider I spoke to) more efficiently used when cutting two 98-inch LCD panels at the same time. Those are huge cuts, and given China’s predilection for market dominance, we may see rapid price drops in 4K TVs across all sizes by the end of 2013.

Speaking of 4K (UHDTV); everyone had it. And I mean everyone! Sony, Panasonic, LG, Samsung, Toshiba, Sharp, Westinghouse, Skyworth, TCL, Hisense, Haier – wait! You never heard of those last four companies? The last three had enormous booths at the show, and Hisense showed five different models of 4K TVs – 50, 58, 65, 84, and 100 inches. That’s more than anyone else had.

In a significant marketing and PR coup, TCL managed to get their 110-inch 4K TV featured in Iron Man III, which debuts in May. That’s the sort of promotional genius that Sony and Panasonic used to pull off. But there are new guys on the block now, and they’re playing for keeps. The steady decline of the Japanese TV industry and continuing financial woes of its major players are all the proof you need.

4koled tv

So – who was REALLY “first” to show a 4K 56-inch OLED TV? Sony, or…


…Panasonic, who also claimed they were the “first?” (Maybe it was a matter of minutes?)

Interestingly, Sony’s booth signs identified this display as the “world’s first and largest OLED TV.” Puzzling, as it clearly wasn’t the first OLED TV ever shown, and just down the hall, Panasonic was showing its 56-inch OLED TV, the “world’s largest 4K OLED created by printing technology.” Both companies need to get out of their booths more often!

Panasonic, who emphatically renewed their commitment to plasma at CES (despite a continued decline in plasma TV sales worldwide), clearly wanted to show they had a second act ready when plasma eventually bites the bullet. The company is also a major player in IPS LCD, manufacturing LCD TVs in sizes to 65 inches that are every bit as good anything LG cranks out.

Speaking of LG…the heavy emphasis on 3D found in last year’s booth was all but gone this year. Yes, the enormous passive 3DTV wall that greeted visitors at the entrance was still there. And there were a few passive 3D demos scattered throughout the booth. But the more impressive exhibit featured a wall of curved 55-inch OLED TVs. (Why would anyone need a curved TV? You’re probably asking. Well, why would anyone need most of the stuff you see at CES?)

LG also showcased a unique product – a 100” projector screen illuminated by an ultra-short-throw laser projector. LG billed it as the world’s largest wall-mount TV (for now) and it’s known as “Hecto.” The projector uses laser diodes (presumably with DLP technology; that wasn’t mentioned) to illuminate that screen at a distance of just 22 inches.

lg oled tv

It’s bad enough that LG shows 55-inch OLED TVs we can’t buy yet. Now, they have curved OLED TVs we can’t buy yet. (Drool…)

3d tv

Got two people who want to watch two different 3D TV programs at the same time? No problem for Samsung!

Back down the hall, LG’s neighbor Samsung also showed a 55-inch curved OLED TV (just one) and a couple of company representatives were surprised to hear that LG had a bevy of them. (I repeat my observation about booth personnel who need to get out more.) Samsung did have a clever demo of an OLED TV showing simultaneous 2K programming – simply change a setting on the 3D glasses and you could watch one or the other show. (TI showed this same trick years ago with DLP RPTVs by switching left eye and right information.)

Samsung did have an 85-inch 4K LCD TV that wasn’t duplicated anywhere else on the show floor, and as far as I can tell, it’s a home-grown product. But given the company’s investment in China Star and its shifting emphasis on AM OLED production, I would not be surprised to see Samsung sourcing more of its LCD glass from China in the near future.

Sharp’s booth intrigued me. Here’s a company on the verge of bankruptcy that was showing a full line of new Quattron LCD TVs, along with “Moth Eye” anti-glare first surface glass. Moth Eye glass preserves high contrast and color saturation, but minimizes reflections in a similar way to a moth’s eye; hence the name. Sharp also had impressive demos of flexible OLEDs and a gorgeous 32-inch 4K LCD monitor.

IGZO was also heralded all around the booth. Indium Gallium Zinc Oxide is a new type of semiconductor layer for switching LCD pixels that consumes less power, passes more light, and switches at faster speeds. Many LCD manufacturers (and OLED manufacturers, too) are working on IGZO, but Sharp is closer to the finish line than anyone else – and that may be the salvation of the company, along with an almost-inevitable orderly bankruptcy.

IGZO is why Terry Gou, the chairman of Hon Hai Precision Industries, wants to buy a piece of Sharp – about 10%, to be exact. He’s looking for a source of VA glass for Apple’s tablets and phones (Hon Hai owns Foxconn, who manufactures these products.) And if Sharp can’t get its financial house in order, he might wind up making a bid for the entire company. (“Never happen!” you say. “The Japanese government wouldn’t allow it.” Well, these are different times we live in, so never say “never!”)


Sharp may not be able to balance their books, but they still know how to manufacture some beautiful displays.


It goes without saying that Tony Stark would have a 110-inch TV, right?

On to the Chinese. They showed 4K, 84-inch and 110-inch LCD glass cuts, gesture recognition, clever LED illumination systems, 3D, smart TVs – basically, everything the Japanese and Koreans were showing. Hisense had a spectacular demo of a transparent 3D LCD TV, along with something called U-LED TV. The explanation of this by the booth representative was so ambiguous that I’ll leave it at an enhanced method of controlling the backlight for improved contrast.

I had heard from an industry colleague that Hisense’s XT880-series 4K TV would have rock-bottom retail prices, but couldn’t confirm this from booth personnel. (Think of $2,000 for a 50-inch 4K TV.) The company’s gesture recognition demo wasn’t nearly as impressive – it’s powered by Israel-based EyeSight – but clearly shows that Hisense is just as far along in refining this feature as anyone else.

TCL had demonstrations of high-contrast 4K TVs with amazingly deep blacks; as good as anything I’ve seen from LG and Samsung. They also had a demonstration of autostereo 3D at the back of their booth, very close to Toshiba (who was showing the same thing). Haier had that now-ubiquitous 4K LCD TV prominently featured in their booth, along with smart TVs and what must have been several dozen tablets. Meanwhile, Skyworth’s booth in the lower south hall showcased yet another 84-inch 4K TV.


RCA’s got the first tablet with an integrated ATSC/MH tuner, and it runs Windows 8.

tv antennas

TV antennas are passe? NOT!


Celluon’s laser-powered virtual keyboard works on any surface. TI had a pair connected to picoprojectors in their suite.

Vizio’s suite at the Wynn featured 80-inch, 70-inch, and 60-inch LCD TVs using the Sharp Gen 10 glass, and they looked impressive. One version of the 70-inch set is already selling below $2,000, and the 80-incher will come in (for now) at just under $4,500. Vizio also had three new 4K TVs in 55-inch, 65-inch, and 70-inch sizes, but no pricing was announced yet. (Everyone is sitting on their hands waiting for the other guy to price his 4K TVs!)

There was obviously a lot more to CES than televisions. Vizio has a new 11.6” tablet with 1920×1080 resolution that runs Windows 8 with a AMD Z-60 processor. Panasonic showed a prototype 20-inch 4K (3840×2560) tablet using IPS-alpha glass. It also runs Windows 8 with an Intel Corei5 CPU and has multi-touch and stylus input. And RCA had a cool 8-inch tablet (Win 8 OS) that incorporates an ATSC receiver and small antenna. It can play back both conventional 8VSB and MH broadcasts.

Silicon Image had a kit-bashed 7” Kindle tablet running their new UltraGig 6400 60 GHz transmitter, delivering 2K video to a bevy of LCD TVs. They also showed a new image scaling chip to convert 2K to 4K, along with the latest version of InstaPrevue. The latter technology lets you see what’s on any connected HDMI input with I-frame thumbnails of video and still images.


Silicon Image’s new UltraGig 6400 TX chip connects this full HD Kindle tablet to an HDTV at 60 GHz.


Conexant’s powerful speech processing chips can filter out any background noise while you “command” your smart TV.


Omek’s gesture control demo was easily the most impressive at the show.

Over in the LV Hotel, Conexant dazzled with a demonstration of adaptive background noise filtering to improve the reliability of voice control systems for televisions. The demo consisted of a nearby loudspeaker playing back an art lecture while commands for TV operation were spoken. A graphical representation showed how effectively the background noise was filtered out completely. The second demo had a Skype conversation running with a TV on in the background and the remote caller walking around the room. I never heard one peep from the TV, and the remote caller was always intelligible.

A few floors down, Omek (yet another Israel-based gesture recognition startup) had perhaps the best demo of gesture control at the show. Their system captures 22 points of reference along your hands, allowing complex gesture control using simple, intuitive finger and wrist movement. (No flailing of arms was necessary). I watched as an operator at a small computer monitor pulled a virtual book from a shelf and flipped through its pages, and also selected a record album, removed the record from its sleeve, and placed it on a virtual turntable. I was even treated to a small marionette show!

At the Renaissance, Prime Sense had numerous exhibits that all revolved around their new, ultra-compact 3D camera design. One demo by Shopperception involved boxes of cereal on a shelf. As you picked one up, the sensors would flash a coupon offer for that cereal to your tablet or phone, or suggest you buy a larger, more economical size instead of two boxes.

Nearby, Covii had one of those “You Are Here” shopping mall locator maps that operated with touchless sensing to expand and provide more detail about any store you were interested in, including sales and promotions. And Matterport had a nifty 3D 360-degree camera that could scan and provide a 3D representation of any room in about one minute. You could then rotate and turn the views in any direction.


Do not – repeat, DO NOT try this at home with your tablet!


A hybrid low rider? With a 500-watt sound system? Who’d a thunk it?


Wear this Garmin GPS watch and nobody can ever tell you to “get lost!”

HzO was back with another amazing demo of their WaterBlock waterproofing system. They had a tablet computer sitting in a continuous shower, and also dunked it in a fish tank. Additional demos included dropping smart phones in a bowl of beer and other mysterious liquids. The water infiltrates all spaces but has no effect on operation – you just drip-dry the device once extracted from water. (How do you get rid of the beer smell, though?)

There was an HDMI pavilion at the show, but I was more interested in the goings-on at the DisplayPort exhibit. VESA representatives showed me a single-channel DP connection from a smart phone to a TV for gaming and playing back video, all over a super-thin connecting cable. The powers that be at VESA are also talking about upping the data rates for DisplayPort (currently about 18 Gb/s) to accommodate higher-resolution TVs.

Right now, DP uses an uncompressed data coding method. But there is now discussion of applying a light compression algorithm (tentatively called DisplayStream) that would enable data rates to go much higher – more like 25 Gb/s. (DisplayPort can currently handle 3840×2160 pixels with 10-bit color and a 60-Hz refresh rate.)

I was surprised at the number of devices at the show that support HDMI, and expected more support for DP given its ability to handle higher data rates and its Thunderbolt data layer overlay. It may still be early in the game – the venerable VGA connector is on its way out starting this year, and manufacturers of laptops, tablets, and phones are still debating which digital interface to hitch their horses to.


No, this is not a typical CES attendee. But it’s how all of us feel after three days at the show.


Panasonic’s 20-inch 4K offering is the Rolls-Royce of tablets. (So who needs a notebook!)


Suffice it to say that this was a VERY popular booth at CES…


…as was this one. Sealy lets you control your mattress settings from your iPad. (Hey, it’s CES!)

Let’s wrap things up with a discussion of ultrabooks. Intel’s booth prominently featured a full line of these next-gen notebooks, although several of the models on display weren’t nearly as thin as I’d expect an ultrabook to be. Shipments of “ultras” in 2012 were only about half of what was forecast.

The reason? Tablets. Vizio’s new tablet is one of the larger models at nearly 12 inches, but Panasonic showed you can go even larger and make it work. At that point, why would you need a notebook? I left mine at home this time and used a Nook HD+ instead. Fitted with a Bluetooth keyboard and mouse, and loaded with Office-compatible programs, it did everything I needed it to do while in Vegas.

Needless to say, the Intel booth representative wasn’t too happy when I pointed this out to him. But that’s the thing about CES: There’s always some other guy at the show that has the same or better product than you. There’s always a better mousetrap or waffle-maker lurking in the South Hall. Very few companies have much of an edge in technology these days (the Chinese brands proved that in spades), and so many of these “wow, gotta have it!” items become commodities in rapid order.

The plethora of 4K and ultra-large LCD TVs found at CES proved this conclusively, as they went from hype to ho-hum in a matter of minutes. So did tablets, smart phones, and other connectivity gadgets. What CES 2013 was really about was the shift in manufacturing prowess and power to China from Japan and Korea; a shift that will only accelerate with time. And that is definitely NOT ho-hum!

Editor’s note: Many thanks and a tip of the hat to Nikon booth personnel, who were apparently charging and swapping out batteries for journalists who (like me) inadvertently ran out of power during the show. They saved me more than once!


Marilyn says, “Gentlemen prefer 4K 3D curved wireless multi-touch OLED IGZO cloud-based voice controlled tablets!” (See you next year…)

The Front Line: Four From Pepcom

Last Thursday (11/15), the Hammerstein Ballroom on 34th Street in New York City was full of tango dancers, Argentine wine, good food – and some interesting products that will get plenty of exposure at January’s International CES.

Pepcom puts on this show several times a year, rotating between the midtown location and the Metropolitan Ballroom on 18th Street.  It’s a chance to get a much more “up close and personal” look at many cutting-edge CE products that would be tough to seek out at larger trade shows.

The November event featured a slew of interesting products from the latest Roomba robotic vacuum cleaners to high-efficiency LED lighting panels and super-dense flash memory sticks and drives. But there were four products in particular that caught my attention.

Lenovo’s IdeaTab Lynx is a clever, hybrid tablet/notebook concept.

Lenovo had a demonstration of its first tablet computer; complete with a snap-on full-size keyboard (the attachment is magnetic). It’s called the IdeaTab Lynx, and is a pretty cool product. The keyboard, which is actually a dock, weighs about 1.5 pounds, and the 11.6-inch screen/tablet comes in just below that. The tablet/screen has a resolution of 1366×768 pixels and employs a 5-point capacitive multi-touch system.

Other features include a 2 MP front camera, 2 GB of DRAM, 32 GB or 64 GB of eMMC storage, and stereo speakers. The IdeaTab Lynx runs Windows 8 from an Intel ATOM dual-core 1.8 GHz processor and battery life is estimated at eight hours for the tablet and another eight hours from the dock. Lenovo has a suggested starting price of $599 for the tablet and another $150 for the keyboard/dock.

Across the aisle, Vizio had its new 70-inch LCD TV set up for inspection. The E701i-A3 Razor LED has all of the usual bells and whistles you’d expect in this size class, including built-in WiFi, a “smart” remote with full QWERTY keyboard, and an extremely slim bezel. Vizio claims the viewable area on this TV is 69.51 inches, and it uses 10-bit signal processing.

Of course, the E701i-A3 comes with Vizio Apps, including access to Netflix, YouTube, Hulu Plus, and Vudu (which together constitute about 85% of all Internet video traffic). Taking a look at the panel, I noticed a resemblance in off-axis performance to Sharp’s 70-inch Aquos and I wouldn’t be surprised if Vizio is sourcing the panel from Sharp. The target MSRP is $1,999, which is where Sharp’s 70-inch Aquos was selling in late January of 2012.

Is this really a Sharp Aquos in Vizio clothing? Could be…


The B&N Nook HD+ adds to an already overcrowded market for tablets, but is competitively priced.


Next to Vizio, I found the folks from Barnes & Noble showing off their latest Nook tablets – the 7-inch Nook HD and the 9-inch Nook HD+. B&N has come a long way in two years from the original Nook reader, and the product migration appears to be towards do-it-all tablets instead of basic readers. (Nook’s Color tablet reader is still in the line, but apparently will be phased out.)

The Nook HD uses a 1440×900 pixel LCD display and is available with 8 GB ($199) or 16 GB ($229) internal flash memory. It runs a Dual-Core 1.3 GHz OMAP4470 processor and the Android OS. I noticed there is support for Google Office, meaning that Microsoft Office documents can be opened and worked on with this tablet. Battery life is rated at 10.5 hours for reading and 9 hours for video.

The Nook HD+ moves up to a 9-inch screen with 1920×1280 (WUXGA) resolution and comes with 16 Gb ($269) or 32 GB ($299) of internal memory. It employs the same processor and OS as the 7-inch tablet and has similar battery life. I found both tablets very bright and contrasty under the overhead spotlights used in the ballroom, and reflection from the LCD screen was minimal. Alas; there’s still no place to make an external display connection like there is on the iPads.

Mohu has decided it’s spending too much time indoors! This Sky HDTV antenna is the result.

Finally, I ventured to the back of the room by the wine bar and ran into the folks from Mohu. Regular readers will recall my frequent tests of indoor TV antennas earlier this year; a competition that Mohu generally won or tied for first place. The news this year is a re-design of the Leaf Plus into the Leaf Ultimate, with the preamplifier now encased in a separate module. You can also buy this preamp by itself as the Jolt Amplifier.

That re-design allowed Mohu to simplify its manufacturing process – just add the Jolt module to an existing Mohu Leaf and you have an Ultimate model. But Mohu isn’t done there: They’ve also unveiled a new outdoor TV antenna that closely resembles a crossed dipole, used by many antenna manufacturers. The Sky HDTV is designed for mast-mounting on a roof or in an attic, and will also work with the Jolt amplifier. No prices have been announced yet.

SID’s New I-Zone Gives Free Space to Tout Innovation at Display Week

by Steve Sechrist

Here in the depths of winter, we learn of a summer holiday bonus from our friends over at SID.  The group just announced a new Innovation Zone (I-Zone for short) to take place at Display Week 2012 in Boston, June 5&6.  The I-Zone exhibit area will “…provide a forum for live demonstrations of emerging information display technologies and related areas…in the main Exhibit Hall,” and here’s the kicker—it’s FREE, courtesy of Charter Sponsor E-Ink Holdings.

The goal is to offer researchers a showcase for cutting-edge demo’s and prototypes, to give a glimpse of “products of tomorrow.”  The I-Zone Committee announced its plans to the Society membership late last week.  (Disclaimer alert, I’m honored to be serving on that committee, along with an august body of the top display world “intelligencia.”)

E-Ink Holdings, known for way-cool prototypes like this one will sponsor the I-Zone at Display Week in Boston, picture credit: engadget

The group is looking for new and novel displays, input technologies (like gesture, voice etc,) and innovations in related fields such as lighting and organic electronics.  Also, technologies should be in the “pre-product” stage, and “…demos that are being shown for the first time in a public forum are particularly encouraged,” the committee reported.

What’s exciting about the concept is, exposure for little known or “under funded” projects, being offered a dedicated area on the show floor.  The hope is to highlight the best the display world has to offer from small companies, startups, universities, government labs, and independent research sites—normally with no possibility of getting this level of focused exposure in the display community or broader public awareness the show can bring.

While the space will be given away free, due to space limitations there is an application and selection process.  This includes submission of a 100 word abstract, a two-page summary describing the novelty and potential application, plus relevant photographs, videos, and / or diagrams; and a brief logistics plan for the intended demo.

A technology diverse group within SID, from various regions throughout the world, will be formed to serve as the selection committee.  Criterion is based on novelty, interest, and quality of the prototype to be exhibited.  Other perks include, an award, to be given at the event, where the I-Zone Committee will select a winner of the “Best Prototype at Display Week 2012” with a writ-up in Information Display magazine.

As mentioned above, sponsor for the event is E-Ink, a company that’s well known for showing a particularly wide variety of display prototypes devices in the past.  At last year’s SID they created a buzz around displays embedded in, jump drives, key fobs, even Music stands and Snowboards.

We think the I-Zone move is truly inspirational, with synergies not just for the principles involved, but offers opportunities to expand awareness of the display industry to the general public, particularly in the host city and surrounding areas.  This year’s site is Boston, an academic and culturally rich environment, where some leading start-up companies have their roots.  This includes the I-Zone the sponsor of record E-Ink that has its research roots at the MIT Media Lab, OK not strictly Boston, but just across the Charles River in Cambridge, MA (“our fair city…”) So plan to kick-off Summer right this year with your spot in the I-Zone, but don’t break out the sun glasses, until you get that Application filled out and submitted for approval.